About Phil Kline

Phil Kline Phil worked as a commercial fisherman for more than 29 years before joining Greenpeace as a Senior Oceans Campaigner in 2007. He has been quoted in the USA Today, The New York Times and Newsweek among others.

WHAT IS THE U.S. THINKING? And whose interests are they defending?

"Why we don't show this same leadership in the international arena is a mystery as deep as the Mariana Trench."

Here I sit for the first time in a rather large conference room at the United Nations building in New York. I’m here for the final informal sessions developing draft text that will be the heart of negotiations next month in Rio at the World Conference on Sustainable Development, Rio+20. As usual, I’m focused on ocean issues, emphatic about the fact that our oceans desperately need a global agreement to stop their ongoing destruction.

Oceans outside areas of national jurisdiction are being plundered by a handful of rich and technologically advanced nations at the expense of the rest of the World. Rio+20 is where we can stop this nonsense, and turn this deplorable situation around. To do that, we need nations to agree on a way forward. Continue reading

The Battle to Save Menhaden Continues….

Take action to save menhaden!

Thanks to you and more than 91,000 other concerned members of the public, the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission passed a precedent-setting conservation measure to protect menhaden.

But now comes the next, and more difficult step in the process — the one where the ASMFC actually figures out how they are going to do it.

Massive companies, like Omega Protein, want to see business continue as usual and are using their influence to push the Commission to delay action for up to another ten years. We’ve come too far already to let that happen.

The Atlantic ecosystem cannot wait any longer! Send your comments today and urge the ASMFC to make menhaden management a priority now.

Continue reading

Big Miracle — A Whale Rescue Movie With a Deeper Message

This is a poor pun, but I can’t resist — I had a whale of time last Wednesday night at the DC premiere of Big Miracle, the new Drew Barrymore movie that features a family of grey whales as her co-stars. This whale of a tale (sorry, I can’t help it) is based on a true story that took place about 20 years ago. Greenpeace activist Cindy Lowry, played by Ms. Barrymore, worked to free an unfortunate whale family that didn’t leave its Arctic summer feeding grounds before the ocean began to freeze over. The whales became trapped five miles from open ocean — a fate that would have meant certain death in the face of the approaching Arctic winter.

The movie is the inspired telling of how Cindy gets a lot of usually at-odds folks to cooperate: The US government, the Soviet Union, Big Oil, the townspeople of Barrow, Alaska, and the indigenous Inupiat community all set differences aside and quite literally save the whales. And while I may be giving away the ending, the real story is just how tough it is to get so many groups of people to find those precious points of understanding that allow them to come together for something greater. It gave me hope that we can certainly do it again.

Ms. Barrymore does a commendable job stepping in to Cindy’s role. My favorite scene is when she uses a bit of clever PR to corner both the US military and a big oil exec, a classic David vs. Goliath moment. That spirit of brains over brawn resonates through the film, which refreshingly reveals Greenpeace as an organization that understands the art of intelligent persuasion. I was half expecting the stereotypical “reckless activist” portrayal, but the film balanced our determination with our compassion; of course we love whales, but we also understand people.

That’s not to say there weren’t a few appropriately firey moments within the frozen landscape. An early scene features Cindy getting kicked out of an oil-lease auction after she demands that the Greenpeace bid be read. That kind of treatment still takes place today as our activists fight climate change, and look for opportunities to speak out wherever they can.

And while this is a heart-warming movie, I hope everyone who sees it leaves the theater with an awareness of some chilly reality. Most of the issues this film introduces are still very much at the top of our agenda today.

Greenpeace tirelessly fights against any and all drilling, and though we don’t object to native communities in the far north taking of a few whales for their survival, we continue to work toward ending all commercial whaling. You can join us by taking action now and asking President Obama to Save the Whales.

This film did a praiseworthy job demonstrating the positive power we, as humans, can generate when we work toward a greater good. It also made it clear that protecting those majestic animals is really a reflection of our commitment to our environment, to our planet, and — ultimately — to ourselves.

Coral Tears in Thailand are Shed for All the World’s Oceans



Coral bleaching means these two fish might have what's left of the reef all to themselves.

CORAL BLEACHING MEANS THESE TWO FISH MIGHT HAVE WHAT’S LEFT OF THE REEF ALL TO THEMSELVES.

Surin Island is your quintessential tropical paradise 60 km off the west coast of Thailand. It has the postcard-pretty beaches, swaying palms, and sparkling ocean. It is also in the midst of one of the world’s most beautiful coral reefs. That’s where my wife and I found ourselves this past Christmas — a sublime natural setting where we hoped to celebrate the holiday. 

Unfortunately, our celebration turned in to a mournful memorial. Strolling along the shore, we found two Thai college girls sitting on the sand, crying openly. Their distress was profound; of course, we stopped to ask what was wrong, and what we could do to help.

But there was nothing we could do. The reason for their grief was far beyond our power to fix. It wasn’t any typical travel inconvenience like a lost passport or stolen credit card. The reason was the reef itself. It was dead.

The girls then told us how they came to this very same place only a year ago, reveling in the reef’s beauty, the lattice of delicate corals, the dazzling spectrum of fish. It was so magnificent that they promised to return for what they hoped would become a tradition of Christmas Day snorkeling.

They had been in the water just minutes before my wife and I walked by, and were grief-stricken because everything that made that reef beautiful was gone. My first snorkeling dive confirmed what those girls saw. A staggering 90% of the hard corals were dead. Just a year ago hundreds — even thousands — of fish frolicked, clouding the reef with bursts of energy and color. Now, there were occasional clusters of perhaps five or six looking lonely and out of place.

So what happened? This pristine ecosystem, a gem in the sea of Southeast Asia, had fallen victim to coral beaching — a horrible phenomenon occuring when the water temperature warms above the long-term average. The corals expel their symbiotic algae, then turn white, and ultimately die. This was the ghostly vision that greeted me on my first dive.

I’ve since learned that this started happening late last year and stretches from India to Singapore. All of Burma, Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam and Malaysia have been seriously affected. During our vacation, we planned to do some reef exploring in Burma and had been warned that the dynamite fishing might put us off, but given the almost complete destruction caused by bleaching,  blowing up the reefs with dynamite now seems mild by comparison.

This heartbreaking reality showed me, in very personal terms, catastrophic impact caused by man-made climate change is very real. It’s not something on the horizon; it’s here today.  Along with bleaching, there’s ice loss, ocean acidification, warming seas, coral reef ecosystem destruction, island nations going under water, unprecedented extreme weather and more. In the case of my beloved reef, its demise is already having a tragic impact on human life as local economies dependent on its health are decimated.

We’re past the point of preparation. The fight for our oceans is upon us, and we all need to get involved if we want to keep even a faint hope that we’ll leave a livable world for future generations.

Please, join us and add your voice in this fight to save our planet. This means so much more than saving pretty dive destinations. This is about the very health of the world in which we live.

We need to fight back against the fossil fuel use that’s accelerating climate change.

We need to establish and protect ocean sanctuaries to give all ocean life a chance to thrive.

From the barely visible plankton to the biggest blue whale, when we save our oceans, we save our planet — and we’ll save ourselves.

Coral Tears in Thailand are Shed for All the World’s Oceans

Coral bleaching means these two fish might have what's left of the reef all to themselves.

Surin Island is your quintessential tropical paradise 60 km off the west coast of Thailand. It has the postcard-pretty beaches, swaying palms, and sparkling ocean. It is also in the midst of one of the world’s most beautiful coral reefs. That’s where my wife and I found ourselves this past Christmas — a sublime natural setting where we hoped to celebrate the holiday.

Unfortunately, our celebration turned in to a mournful memorial. Strolling along the shore, we found two Thai college girls sitting on the sand, crying openly. Their distress was profound; of course, we stopped to ask what was wrong, and what we could do to help.

Continue reading

Japan’s Shame Goes Up Once Again

Nisshin Maru Factory Vessel

Yesterday we learned that once again Japan’s whaling fleet has left port and is heading to the International Whale Sanctuary in the Southern Ocean to continue its annual whale slaughter. With Japan still reeling from their recent earthquake, tsunami, and Fukushima nuclear disasters — to spend more taxpayer money to support their whaling program is nothing short of shameful. My Japanese colleague, Junichi Sato (Executive Director of Greenpeace Japan) had this to say as the fleet departed –  

Not only is the whaling industry unable to survive without large increases in government handouts, now it’s siphoning money away from the victims of the March 11 triple disaster, at a time when they need it most. This is a new low for the shameful whaling industry and the callous politicians that support it. Japan’s whaling program is already a black mark on the country’s international reputation; the government should focus on recovery at home rather than continuing this shameful Antarctic whale hunt. It is time for the Japanese government to do the right thing by its people, the international community and the environment by committing to drop its financial support for the whaling industry for once and for all.”  

I fail to see how wasting taxpayer money on hunting whales in an International Whale Sanctuary can be seen as anything other than an international embarrassment.

Japan’s politicians that again supported increased subsidies to fund yet another year of needless whale slaughter have turned their backs on their own citizens and their ability to recovery from multiple disasters – their behavior is nothing short of shameful.

Photo: The Nisshin Maru factory ship, of the Japanese whaling fleet, departs Japan to head to the Southern Ocean to begin the whaling season of 2010-2011.

Japan’s Shame Goes Up Once Again

By: Phil Kline

Nisshin Maru Factory Vessel

Yesterday we learned that once again Japan’s whaling fleet has left port and is heading to the International Whale Sanctuary in the Southern Ocean to continue its annual whale slaughter. With Japan still reeling from their recent earthquake, tsunami, and Fukushima nuclear disasters — to spend more taxpayer money to support their whaling program is nothing short of shameful. My Japanese colleague, Junichi Sato (Executive Director of Greenpeace Japan) had this to say as the fleet departed –

“Not only is the whaling industry unable to survive without large increases in government handouts, now it’s siphoning money away from the victims of the March 11 triple disaster, at a time when they need it most. This is a new low for the shameful whaling industry and the callous politicians that support it. Japan’s whaling program is already a black mark on the country’s international reputation; the government should focus on recovery at home rather than continuing this shameful Antarctic whale hunt. It is time for the Japanese government to do the right thing by its people, the international community and the environment by committing to drop its financial support for the whaling industry for once and for all.”

I fail to see how wasting taxpayer money on hunting whales in an International Whale Sanctuary can be seen as anything other than an international embarrassment.

Japan’s politicians that again supported increased subsidies to fund yet another year of needless whale slaughter have turned their backs on their own citizens and their ability to recovery from multiple disasters – their behavior is nothing short of shameful.

Photo: The Nisshin Maru factory ship, of the Japanese whaling fleet, departs Japan to head to the Southern Ocean to begin the whaling season of 2010-2011.

Another Win for Whales: Endangered Fin Whales get help from President Obama

Yesterday President Obama took a step in the right direction to meet his campaign promise to work to end commercial whaling.

The President imposed diplomatic sanctions on Iceland over their commercial Fin whale hunting as recommended in July by the Secretary of Commerce Gary Locke.

Together we can help save the whales – take action right now.

Although we would have liked to see trade sanctions included in President Obama’s action the diplomatic sanctions he has now imposed will keep a spotlight from the US government on Iceland’s Fin whaling with the clear directive from the US government that it has to end.

Moving in the right direction is always a good thing and we applaud the President’s action. Below is an excerpt from the President’s letter to Congress detailing the action he took yesterday:

“In his letter of July 19, 2011, Secretary Locke expressed his concern for these actions, and I share these concerns. To ensure that this issue continues to receive the highest level of attention, I direct:

(1) relevant U.S. delegations attending meetings with Icelandic officials and senior Administration officials visiting Iceland to raise U.S. concerns regarding commercial whaling by Icelandic companies and seek ways to halt such action;

(2) Cabinet secretaries to evaluate the appropriateness of visits to Iceland depending on continuation of the current suspension of fin whaling;

(3) the Department of State to examine Arctic cooperation projects, and where appropriate, link U.S. cooperation to the Icelandic government changing its whaling policy and abiding by the IWC moratorium on commercial whaling;

(4) the Departments of Commerce and State to consult with other international actors on efforts to end Icelandic commercial whaling and have Iceland abide by the IWC moratorium on commercial whaling;

(5) the Department of State to inform the Government of Iceland that the United States will continue to monitor the activities of Icelandic companies that engage in commercial whaling; and

(6) relevant U.S. agencies to continue to examine other options for responding to continued whaling by Iceland.”   President Barack Obama, September 15, 2011

You can read President Obama’s full letter to Congress at:

http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2011/09/15/message-president-congress

What’s for dinner asks Mr Striped Bass – Menhaden?

It has been one year since I last wrote about Menhaden. However it has taken a year of multi pronged advocacy from the Menhaden Coalition to get to the point where the Atlantic States Marine Fish Commission (ASMFC) has finally taken a significant action to reform menhaden management.

Menhaden? You might be asking yourself what the heck is a Menhaden. Menhaden are a small oily fish that is actually one of the most important fish in the sea. The tiny fish is a major prey species for Striped Bass, Bluefish, multiple bird species, whales and a host of other marine animals. Menhaden are keystone species and a major foundation of the coastal food web from New England to Florida.

It’s been said that if you eat a wild fish you’re eating Menhaden. They have been seriously overfished and the population is currently less than 10 percent of their unfished level. This is the lowest population level ever recorded. The ecosystem is feeling this stress as all of the species dependant on Menhaden can’t find enough food from starving Striped Bass to Ospreys. Over the past 25 years under the management of the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commisison (ASMFC), the Menhaden population has plummeted. The ASMFC has “managed” Menhaden for the benefit of one company, Omega Protein, which grinds them up for industrial uses like fertilizer and animal feed.

The ASMFC after years of ignoring the extreme ecosystem overfishing and depletion of menhaden yesterday passed a draft menhaden management plan addendum that will now be sent out for public comment. This draft proposal, if adopted, at their November meeting will fundamentally change menhaden management and put it on the road to ecosystem based management – this is a huge victory.

Greenpeace has been involved in the political process to reform the management of the menhaden fishery for almost a decade. This is the first meaningful step forward in all of that time. The ASMFC action is only the first step in a very long process that will eventually change the management of menhaden from it’s current ‘industrial exploitation is the only thing that matters’ role to one where recognizing and maintaining their valuable role in the ecosystem is of paramount importance. To put this in plain English, we are finally going to ask what striped bass, bluefish, sea birds and a host of other dependent species need for dinner [select]and give them their dinner first before any industrial fisheries catch what’s left. To learn about the details go to www.SaveMenhaden.org.

In the very near future we will let you know how you can join us in this fight to save Menhaden – The Most Important Fish in the Sea.

Here’s an excellent news article by Candy Thomson of the Baltimore Sun.

Whales Win Another Round

July has proven to be an incredible month for whales with 2 back to back victories. Last week at the International Whaling Commission’s (IWC) meeting they changed their rules of procedure to address the rampant corruption of their process caused by Japan’s vote buying by no longer allowing a country to pay their dues using cash, credit cards or other non transparent means. However the good news for whales didn’t stop there as the US government formally put Iceland on notice that their hunting of endangered Fin whales has to end.

On Wed. the 20th the US government announced that under the ‘Pelly Amendment’ they have certified Iceland’s Fin whale hunt. Mr. Locke, our Secretary of Commerce, had this to say in NOAA’s press release announcing the US government’s decision –

The United States has strongly and repeatedly objected to Iceland’s commercial whaling. Under the Pelly Amendment to the U.S. Fishermen’s Protective Act of 1967, the Secretary of Commerce certifies to the President that “nationals of a foreign country . . . are conducting fishing operations in a manner or under circumstances which diminish the effectiveness of an international fishery conservation program.”

“Iceland’s disregard for the International Whaling Commission’s (IWC) global moratorium on commercial whaling is unacceptable,” said Mr Locke.

“Its harvest of whales and export of fin whale meat threaten an endangered species and undermine worldwide efforts to protect whales.

“It’s critical that the government of Iceland take immediate action to comply with the moratorium.”

The decision of the US government to take this strong action against Iceland only happened because of all your voices encouraging the US government to do exactly that. Greenpeace activists and supporters sent approximately 40,000 messages to both Secretary of State Clinton and also to Mr. Locke the Secretary of Commerce – GREAT JOB EVERYONE!!! Your voices made this an issue our government couldn’t ignore – Thank You.

Now President Obama has 60 days to decide on what sanctions the US will impose on Iceland to push them along to end their senseless Fin whale hunt forever. We will continue to engage with President Obama and his staff urging the US government to impose trade sanctions on Icelandic marine products that come from the companies involved in their Fin whale slaughter. This is primarily cod fillets they export to US markets.

It is beginning to appear that the US government’s action this week is getting some traction inside Iceland. Colleagues of ours who closely follow internal Icelandic politics have told me that this Pelly Certification was the biggest news of the day on almost all of Iceland’s media outlets. This news caused a round of blog discussions in Iceland with many folks questioning why Iceland allows one company to tarnish Iceland’s international reputation when the country gets zero benefits from it. This discussion has reached some high places inside Iceland’s government:

Árni Þór Sigurðsson, chairman of the Althingi’s Foreign Affairs Committee, said today (Wed 20th) on his facebook page that “whaling is damaging the commercial and political interests of Iceland. It should stop.”

Now that powerful elected officials are openly opposing their Fin whaling we might be seeing the first signs that things will change and Iceland will actually end their Fin whaling.

Keep your fingers crossed. Our advocacy is working and we will keep pushing until Iceland’s Fin whaling is history.